I'm not sure how I feel about everyone being on Substack

Everyone and their mom is on Substack now and I really don’t know how I feel about it.

Substacks aren’t really blogs; they’re part of an ecosystem that feels a little bit like the social mediaification of blogging.

Blogging is supposed to be one of the last defences against the shackles of social media expectations, but I feel like Substack centralizing so much of the long form discourse on the internet can’t be good. Every once in a while I consider getting on Substack, but it just feels wrong for some reason. I believe in people having their own space on the internet.

Read more...

Reading Academic Papers Is a Nightmare

So I’ve been saying for a while that reading academic papers is a skill. However, what I didn’t realize is that having a pretty good idea of how to read a paper from one discipline doesn’t quite map to knowing how to approach a paper from another field. Academic papers are all confusing nightmares, but papers from different disciplines are nightmarish in different ways, which means that while some parts of the basic reading approach can stay the same, others will have to be discarded or relearned.
Read more...

Why Does Theory Matter in Computer Science? (Meta-Commentary)

Note on the Making (Writing?) of this Talk/Series

When I first started doing this writeup, I did not expect to still be working on it 6 months later. Finishing this was a long, long overdue task for a while. This is the second write-up I’ve done of a talk I’ve given. The first one I did was for “How to be a Talentless Hack in Public”, which I published in zine form first, before then publishing the text on this blog several months later.
Read more...

If researchers don't advance public knowledge, who will?

Here’s a thought: The set of “public knowledge” and the set of “human knowledge” are very different things: the first is a strict subset of the latter.

Researchers get paid to advance human knowledge. They do NOT paid to advance public knowledge.

So who advances “public knowledge”? Is it journalists? Educators? Should it be the burden of researchers?

Here’s another question: should all human knowledge be packaged in such a way that the public understands it? Is that a good use of time and resources? Does the average person actually need to be able to understand the newest developments in esoteric fields?

Read more...